Article proposes including new diagnostic subcategories ‘atypical urothelial cells of undetermined significance’ (AUC-US) and ‘cannot exclude high grade’ (AUC-H) for urine cytology reports.
E. Piaton, M. Decaussin-Petrucci, F. Mege-Lechevallier, A.-S. Advenier, M. Devonec, A. Ruffion
NOTE: It would be interesting to see how reflex molecular testing or cytology-plus molecular testing correlated with these findings as well, if available. (Unfortunately, I don’t yet have my copy of the full article to see if this was provided in the fine print. The Populist Cytologist)
We studied whether atypical, non-superficial urothelial cells (AUC) could be separated into new subcategories including AUC ‘of undetermined significance’ (AUC-US) and ‘cannot exclude high grade’’ (AUC-H) in order to help to standardize urine cytopathology reports, as it is widely accepted in the Bethesda system for gynaecological cytopathology.
We investigated whether AUC-US and AUC-H, defined by distinctive cytological criteria, might be separated with statistical significance according to actual diagnosis and follow-up data. A series of 534 cyto-histological comparisons taken in 139 patients, including 221 AUC at various steps of their clinical history was studied. There were 513 (96.1%) postcystoscopy and 469 (87.8%) ThinPrep® liquid-based specimens (95.9% and 89.1% of AUC cases, respectively). Patients viewed between 1999 and 2011 had histological control in a 0- to 6-months delay and were followed-up during an additional 5.9 ± 9.2 (0- to 56-) months period.
The 221 AUC represented 0.8–2% of the specimens viewed during the study period. Among AUC-H cases, 70 out of 185 (37.8%) matched with high-grade lesions, compared with 3 of 38 (8.3%) of AUC-US cases (P = 0.0003). Conservatively treated patients with AUC-H more frequently developed high-grade lesions than those with AUC-US (54.1% versus 16.7%, P = 0.0007) with a 17.6-months mean delay. Nuclear hyperchromasia, a nuclear to cytoplasm (N/C) ratio > 0.7 and the combination of both were the more informative diagnostic criteria, all with P < 0.01.